← All Insights
Real TalkNovember 19, 2026·6 min read

Real Estate Advice at the Thanksgiving Table: What to Take, What to Leave

Thanksgiving is next Thursday, and if you have mentioned that you are thinking about buying or selling a home, you already know what is coming. Your uncle will tell you rates were 18 percent when he bought and you should stop complaining. Your cousin will tell you to wait for the crash. Someone will tell you renting is throwing money away, and someone else will tell you buying is a scam. Your mother will want to know why you would ever live in that part of town.

Most of it comes from love. Some of it is genuinely useful. And some of it is advice from a housing market that no longer exists. Here is a guide to sorting it out.

Advice Worth Taking Seriously

Do not buy more house than you can comfortably afford. This is the most common piece of family advice, and it is almost always right. Lenders approve you for a maximum, not a recommendation. The people who love you have watched someone stretch too far and spend years house-poor, and they do not want that for you. Build a budget around what you are comfortable paying each month, including taxes, insurance, HOA or metro district fees, and maintenance, not around what a lender says you can borrow.

Keep an emergency fund after closing. Also right. Furnaces break, sewer lines collapse, and hail storms happen. Buyers who drain every dollar for a down payment are one bad month away from real stress.

Buy for how you will live, not for resale. Older relatives often have the wisdom of having lived in a few houses, and they know which compromises got old fast. A long commute, a tiny kitchen, or a layout that does not fit your family can make a good investment a bad home.

Get it inspected. If your father-in-law insists you get a sewer scope and a radon test, he is right. In Colorado, both are cheap compared to what they can uncover.

Advice That Needs Context

Rates were higher when we bought. True, and in the early 1980s, mortgage rates were far higher than they are today. But home prices relative to income were also very different. The challenge for buyers today is not just the rate; it is the rate applied to much larger loan balances. Both things can be true: rates have been worse, and affordability is still genuinely hard right now.

Renting is throwing money away. Not exactly. Rent buys you housing, flexibility, and no maintenance bills. Owning builds equity over time, but it comes with transaction costs, repairs, property taxes, and less flexibility. If you might move within a few years, renting can be the smarter financial choice. If you plan to stay put, owning has historically built wealth for most Colorado households. The honest answer depends on your timeline.

Just offer less. Sometimes the right offer is well below list price, and sometimes it is above it. It depends on the specific home, how long it has been on the market, and what comparable homes have sold for. We wrote about this recently: lowball offers work when the data and the listing's situation support them, and they backfire when they do not.

Advice You Can Probably Leave on the Table

Wait for the crash. People have predicted a Denver housing crash for most of the last fifteen years. Prices can fall, and they have softened in some submarkets, but timing a market is not a plan. If you need a home and can afford it, life timing usually matters more than market timing. If you want the long version, we wrote about whether to wait for rates to drop earlier this fall.

You do not need an agent anymore, everything is online. Information is online. Representation, negotiation, contract knowledge, and someone accountable to you are not. You can certainly sell or buy without an agent, but understand what you are giving up. Ironically, the relatives who give this advice often used an agent for every home they ever bought.

Never buy a condo. Or never buy new construction, or never buy an older home, or never buy anything with an HOA. Blanket rules make for good dinner conversation and bad decisions. Every property type has trade-offs. The right answer depends on the specific building, the specific HOA budget, the specific builder, and your goals.

Use my friend, she is a Realtor. Maybe. If your relative's friend is experienced, works in your area, and you would hire her even if you did not know her, great. If not, choosing an agent to avoid an awkward holiday conversation can cost you real money.

How to Handle the Conversation

Listen first. Even outdated advice usually contains a real concern. When your grandmother tells you not to buy in a particular neighborhood, she may be worried about your safety. When your father says rates are fine, he may be trying to tell you not to let fear stop you. Responding to the concern instead of the specifics keeps the peace and sometimes surfaces useful questions.

Have a short answer ready. Something like, we are working with a lender and an agent, we have a budget we are comfortable with, and we are taking our time. That tends to end the cross-examination without a debate over dessert.

Do not make a decision at the table. If someone raises a point that makes you uneasy, write it down and bring it to your lender or agent next week. A good professional will either explain why it does not apply to your situation or help you adjust your plan.

And keep the numbers private if you want to. You do not owe anyone your pre-approval amount, your offer price, or your expected sale price.

The Bottom Line

Family advice is free, and sometimes it is worth exactly that. But some of the best real estate wisdom we have heard came from parents and grandparents who learned it the hard way. Take the advice that protects your budget and your peace of mind, put the rest in context, and enjoy the pie. From all of us at Emblem Real Estate, have a wonderful Thanksgiving.

Have questions?

We're here to help.

Whether you're buying, selling, or just curious — reach out anytime.

Contact UsMore Insights